Principles of Political Economy

John Stuart Mill

Length Emails required
3,016 lines 76 (based on one per day)

Preview - part 73 of 76

335 See “Economics of Industry,” by Mr. and Mrs. Marshall, p. 223. 336 “Wealth of Nations,” Book V, chap. ii. 337 Book II, Chap. I, § 6. 338 Book III, Chap. XIX, § 5. 339 A higher rate is now imposed on landed than on professional incomes. 340 Cf. Walker, “Land and Rent,” page 134. 341 I have changed the sums mentioned in this illustration into our own money. 342 Another common objection is that large and expensive accommodation is often required, not as a residence, but for business. But it is an admitted principle that buildings, or portions of buildings, occupied exclusively for business, such as shops, warehouses, or manufactories, ought to be exempted from house-tax. It has been also objected that house-rent in the rural districts is much lower than in towns, and lower in some towns and in some rural districts than in others; so that a tax proportioned to it would have a corresponding inequality of pressure. To this, however, it may be answered that, in places where house-rent is low, persons of the same amount of income usually live in larger and better houses, and thus expend in house-rent more nearly the same proportion of their incomes than might at first sight appear. Or, if not, the probability will be that many of them live in those places precisely because they are too poor to live elsewhere, and have, therefore, the strongest claim to be taxed lightly. In some cases it is precisely because the people are poor that house-rent remains low.—MILL. 343 I have here also changed the amounts into our own money. 344 This illustration has also been changed, but only so far as to fit the trade between England and the United States. 345 Probably the strongest known instance of a large revenue raised from foreigners by a tax on exports is the opium-trade with China. The high price of the article under the Government monopoly (which is equivalent to a high export duty) has so little effect in discouraging its consumption that it is said to have been occasionally sold in China for as much as its weight in silver.—MILL. 346 A land-tax is, to its extent, an evidence that the state claims a certain right in the soil, and that it stands to the contributor, as it were, in the place of a landlord. This tax, however, is generally so small that it does not materially diminish the rent of land. So far as it goes, it is a tax on rent. 347 Some argue that the materials and instruments of all production should be exempt from taxation; but these, when they do not enter into the production of necessaries, seem as proper subjects of taxation as the finished article. It is chiefly with reference to foreign trade that such taxes have been considered injurious. Internationally speaking, they may be looked upon as export duties, and, unless in cases in which an export duty is advisable, they should be accompanied with an equivalent drawback on exportation. But there is no sufficient reason against taxing the materials and instruments used in the production of anything which is itself a fit object of taxation.—MILL. 348 See Lalor’s “Cyclopædia,” article “Distilled Spirits,” by David A. Wells. 349 “United States Statistical Abstract,” 1883, pp. 2, 3. 350 The old condition of things was well described by Sydney Smith: “We must pay taxes upon every article which enters into the mouth or covers the back, or is placed under the foot. Taxes upon everything which is pleasant to see, hear, feel, smell, and taste. Taxes upon warmth, light, and locomotion. Taxes upon everything upon earth and the waters under the earth. On everything that comes from abroad or is grown at home. Taxes on raw material. Taxes on every value that is added to it by the industry of man. Taxes on the sauce which pampers man’s appetite and the drug which restores him to health. On the ermine which decorates the judge and the rope which hangs the criminal. On the brass nails of the coffin and on the ribbons of the bride. At bed or at board, couchant or levant, we must pay. The beardless youth manages his taxed horse with a taxed bridle on a taxed road, and the dying Englishman, pouring his medicine (which has paid 7 per cent) into a spoon (which has paid 30 per cent), throws himself back upon his chintz bed (which has paid 22 per cent), makes his will, and expires in the arms of the apothecary (who has paid £100 for the privilege of putting him to death). His whole property is then taxed from 2 to 10 per cent; besides the probate, large fees are demanded for burying him in the chancel: his virtues are handed down to posterity on taxed marble, and he is then gathered to his fathers to be taxed no more.” 351 “Financial Reform Almanac,” 1883, pp. 107-109. 352 “Handbuch der Verfassung und Verwaltung in Preussen und dem Deutschen Reich,” by Graf Hue de Grais (second edition, 1882), p. 138. 353 “Le Budget. Revenus et Dépenses de la France,” by M. Block (1881), pp. 57, 82. 354 Taken, with modifications, from Milnes’s “Problems in Political Economy,” p. 377. 355 Book I, Chap. IV, § 5. 356 Although Mr. Mill had reference to the French wars in the beginning of this century, his words apply also to the circumstances of our own late war, 1861-1865. 357 Cairnes, “Leading Principles,” pp. 381, 382. 358 Book I, Chap. IV. 359 Mr. Mill here takes up political considerations, which are not properly to be included in a purely economic treatment. (See the beginning of § 6.) 360 See “Sketch of the History of Political Economy,” _supra_, p. 6, note 1. 361 For bibliography of the United States shipping question, see Appendix I. 362 D. A. Wells, “Cobden Club Essays,” second series, p. 533. 363 See F. W. Taussig’s “Protection to Young Industries as applied in the United States” (1883). 364 In a letter written February 26, 1866, to Mr. Horace White, published in the Chicago “Tribune,” and reprinted in the New York “Nation,” May 29, 1873. 365 Business men constantly use the term “cost of production” when in reality they mean that which to the economist is expressed by “cost of labor.” If cost of labor becomes higher, it takes from profits—the place where they feel the difficulties of competition—but they say that the cost of production has risen: the cost, to them, only has risen, that is, the “cost of labor,” not “cost of production.” 366 Cf. Cairnes, “Leading Principles,” pp. 324-341; and _supra_, Book III, Chap. II, § 4. 367 The fact (sufficiently established by Mr. Brassey) is not considered also that England gives higher wages to operatives than the Continent, and yet England is able to undersell France and Germany in neutral markets. It is evident, however, that England can undersell only in occupations in which she has advantages. 368 Cairnes, “Leading Principles,” pp. 382-388. 369 “Compendium,” 1880, pp. 1343-1377. 370 “Princeton Review,” 1883, p. 222. 371 The United States have at the present time but five persons engaged in agriculture for each square mile of settled area. 372 Book IV, Chap. I, § 2. 373 “Fifteenth Annual Report of the Massachusetts Bureau of Statistics, 1884,” by Carroll D. Wright.