Principles of Political Economy

John Stuart Mill

Length Emails required
3,016 lines 76 (based on one per day)

Preview - part 72 of 76

296 “Leading Principles,” Part I, chap. v. 297 For the distinction between normal and market values, see _supra_, Book III, Chap. II, § 4, and p. 269. 298 Before beginning this discussion the reader is advised to review the relation of profits to cost of labor, and the dependence of the latter on its three factors, Book II, Chap. V, § 5. 299 Book I, Chap. IX 300 Mr. Mill commended, as the most scientific treatment of the subject with which he had met, an “Essay on the Effects of Machinery,” by William Ellis, “Westminster Review,” January, 1826. 301 Although their needs now attract more attention through the extension of newspapers and cheap books, the condition of the laboring-class is certainly better than it was fifty years ago. See Mr. Robert Giffen’s “Progress of the Working-Classes in the Last Half-Century” (1884), referred to in Book IV, Chap. V, § 1. 302 A comparison of Chart No. XVII with Chart No. VI will furnish some means of learning whether the building of railways has gone on faster than is warranted by the increase of our crops (see _supra_, pp. 138). 303 Book I, Chap. V, § 2. 304 Book II, Chap. I, § 6. 305 “Progress of the Working-Classes in the Last Half-Century” (1884), page 8. 306 “Leading Principles,” pp. 278-280. 307 “Progress of the Working-Classes in the Last Half-Century” (1884), being his inaugural address as President of the London Statistical Society, November 20, 1883. 308 1825. 309 1825. 310 Wages per day. 311 Wages per day. 312 Year 1878. 313 These mills have not been able to pay ten per cent regularly, as mentioned in Chart No. XIX, but it has merely been supposed that ten per cent were demanded by capital, in order to show that, for such a dividend, it required a diminishing proportion of the price to meet that estimate. 314 Book II, Chap. V, § 5; see also “North American Review,” May, 1884, p. 517. 315 For the influences of small properties in restraining an undue increase of population, see _supra_, p. 119. For a more general account of the benefits arising from such holdings, consult Mill’s original work, Book II, Chaps. VI and VII, and T. E. Cliffe Leslie’s “Land Systems.” 316 Cf. E. L. Godkin, “North American Review,” 1868, p. 150. 317 Fawcett, “Manual of Political Economy” (last edition), chapter on Co-operation. 318 Giffen, “Progress of the Working-Classes in the Last Half-Century,” p. 19. 319 “History of Co-operation in England” (2 vols., 1879), p. 105. 320 Mr. Holyoake (“History of Co-operation in England,” p. 99) quotes as follows from another’s experience: “My own pass-book shows that I paid on November 3d, of last year (1860), £1 to become a member of a co-operative store. I have paid nothing since, and I am now credited with £3 16_s._ 6_d._, nearly three hundred per cent on my capital in a single year. Of course, that arises from my purchases having been large in proportion to my investment. In a co-operative store you get five per cent upon the money which you invest as a shareholder; and, if the store be well conducted, you will get seven and a half per cent addition.” 321 For a full account of the proper steps to be taken in establishing a store, with many practical details, see Charles Barnard’s “Co-operation as a Business,” p. 119. 322 Cf. Walker, “Wages Question,” p. 276. 323 Godkin, “North American Review,” 1868. 324 “History of Co-operation,” vol. ii, chap. ix. 325 Holyoake, “History of Co-operation,” p. 131. 326 Godkin, “North American Review,” 1868. 327 Pp. 27, 31, 32. 328 Barnard, “Co-operation as a Business,” pp. 150-152. 329 Holyoake, “History of Co-operation,” p. 235. 330 See Thornton, “On Labor,” p. 370. Also see “Parliamentary Documents,” 1868, 1869, xxxi; “Trades-Unions of England,” by the Count de Paris; Brassey’s “Work and Wages,” chap. xiii. 331 See Walker, “Wages Question,” p. 283. Also see Mill, Book IV, Chap. VII, § 5, for an account of M. Leclaire’s experiments in France with house-painters. 332 See also Von Böhmert, “Gewinnbetheiligung,” second edition, 1878, and Jevons’s “Methods of Social Reform” (1883). Professor Jevons (“The State in Relation to Labor,” pp. 146, 147) has given a brief bibliography, which I reproduce here: Charles Babbage, “Economy of Manufactures,” chap. xxvi; H. C. Briggs, “Social Science Association,” 1869; H. C. and A. Briggs, “Evidence before the Trades-Union Commission,” March 4, 1868, Questions 12,485 to 12,753 [Parliamentary Documents]; “The Industrial Partnerships Record”; Pare, “Co-operative Agriculture” (Longmans) 1870; Jean Billon, “Participation des Ouvriers aux Bénéfices des Patrons,” Genève, 1877; Fougerousse, “Patrons et Ouvriers de Paris” (Chaix), 1880; Sedley Taylor, “Society of Arts Journal,” February 18, 1881, vol. xxix, pp. 260-270; also in “Nineteenth Century,” May, 1881, pp. 802-811, “On Profit-Sharing”; J. C. Van Marken, “La Question Ouvrière: Essai de Solution Pratique” (Chaix) 1881. 333 In his last edition of his “Manual,” Professor Fawcett thus describes a co-operative experiment in agriculture: “The one that has attracted the most attention was made nearly forty years since by Mr. Gurdon, on his estate at Assington, near Sudbury, in Suffolk. Mr. Gurdon was so much impressed with the miserable condition of the agricultural laborers who were employed on his estate, that he was prompted to do something on their behalf. When, therefore, one of his farms became vacant, he offered to let it at the ordinary rent, £150 a year, to the laborers who worked upon it. As they, of course, had not sufficient capital to cultivate it, he in the first instance loaned them the requisite stock and implements. The laborers were, in fact, formed into a company in which there were eleven shares, and no laborer was permitted to hold more than one share. The plan was so eminently successful that in a few years sufficient had been saved out of the profits to repay all that had been advanced, and the stock and implements became the property of the laborers. Each share greatly increased in value. Mr. Gurdon was so much encouraged, not only by the pecuniary advantages secured to the laborers, but also by the general improvement effected in their condition, that some years afterward he let another and a larger farm on similar terms. Although no statement of accounts has ever been published, the remarkable pecuniary advantages secured to the laborers is proved by the fact that, after enjoying at least as high wages as were paid in the district, they were able in a few years to become the owners of a valuable property, consisting of the stock and implements on the farms. One of the most significant and hopeful circumstances connected with the experiment is, that it was not carried out by a picked body of men; and if so much could be done by laborers who were probably among the worst educated in the country, it maybe fairly concluded, that when the intelligence of our rural population has been better developed, co-operation may be applied in a more complete form to agriculture, and with even more striking results than were obtained at Assington.... In the description which has been frequently given of the system of peasant proprietorship, it is shown how powerfully the industry of the laborer is stimulated by the feeling of property. When he cultivates his own plot of ground, he exerts himself to the utmost, because he knows that he will enjoy all that is yielded by his labor. Each year, with the extended use of machinery in agriculture, it is becoming more advantageous to carry on farming on a large scale. When, therefore, co-operative agriculture becomes practicable, land may be cultivated by associations of laborers, and thus many of the advantages associated with the system of peasant proprietorship may be secured, while at the same time the disadvantages of small farming may be avoided. The progress toward co-operative agriculture will no doubt be slow and gradual.” 334 Godkin, “North American Review,” 1868. Also see Hermann Schultze-Delitsch, “Die Entwickelung des Genossenschaftswesens in Deutschland” (1870). This eminent philanthropist died April 29, 1883. For other forms of co-operation, building associations, etc., see Barnard, “Co-operation as a Business”; Pajot, “Du Progrès par les Sociétés de Secours Mutuels” (1878).