Principles of Political Economy

John Stuart Mill

Length Emails required
3,016 lines 76 (based on one per day)

Preview - part 56 of 76

57. What arguments does Mr. Mill suggest in favor of some redistribution of landed property? 58. What are the economic arguments for and against Communism? 59. In what way, and by what means, do Socialists want to alter the present distribution of wealth? 60. Sketch the principal forms of Communistic and Non-communistic Socialism. 61. Should the power of bequest be limited? WAGES. 62. On what, according to Mill, does the rate of wages depend? Hence, show the fallacy of the popularly proposed remedies for low wages. 63. State and examine the principal theories which have been put forward as to the circumstances which regulate the general rate of wages, saying which you deem to be correct, and why so. 64. Mr. Thornton argues that the wages-fund is neither “determined” nor “limited”: not “determined,” because there is no “law” to compel capitalists to devote any portion of their wealth to the payment of labor, nor are they morally “bound” to do so; and not “limited,” because there is nothing to prevent them from adding to the portion of their wealth so applied. Criticise this argument, and, if you dissent from Mr. Thornton’s view, state the causes which “determine” and “limit” the fund in question. 65. State precisely what you mean by the “wages-fund,” and explain the conditions on which its growth depends. 66. Explain generally the circumstances which determine the rate of wages. Mention some of the reasons why wages should be higher in one occupation than in another. 67. In what way does dearness or cheapness of food affect money wages? 68. What determines— (1.) The general rate of wages in a country? (2.) The relative rates of wages in different employments? 69. What causes different rates of wages in different employments, and by what methods might wages be raised? 70. How do you explain the fact that some of the most disagreeable kinds of labor are the most badly paid? 71. What, according to Mr. Mill, are the most promising means for the improvement of the laboring-classes? 72. In the Island of Laputa a law was passed compelling each workman to work with his left hand tied behind his back, and the law was justified on the ground that the demand for labor was more than doubled by it. Examine this argument. 73. Some coal-workers are calling for a diminution of the output of coal, so as to keep up their wages. Examine how far, if at all, this result would follow from their proposed action. 74. Discuss any remedies for low wages that have been or might be suggested. 75. Why are the wages of women habitually lower than those of men? PROFITS. 76. What is the cause of the existence of profits? And what, according to Mr. Mill, are the circumstances which determine the respective shares of the laborer and the capitalist? 77. (1.) What is the lowest rate of profit which can permanently exist? (2.) Why is this minimum variable? 78. Analyze the remuneration received by any of the following: (1) the proprietor of a cotton-mill managing his own mill; (2) a merchant conducting his own business; (3) a railway shareholder; (4) a holder of government funds. 79. Into what portions may we divide the return which is usually called profit? Which of these portions would be received by a merchant carrying on business with borrowed capital? 80. Analyze the payment called profits into its various elements. Point out in what respects the earnings of the employer differ from or resemble the wages paid to other classes of laborers. 81. It is asserted that “profits tend to an equality.” What conditions must be satisfied before this position can be maintained? 82. How is the alleged tendency of profits to equivalence in different employments to be reconciled with the notorious difference in the profit of different individuals? 83. Which one of the elements in profit has the greatest effect on its amount? Explain by comparing the causes which regulate each element. 84. How does Mill reconcile the high wages in America with Ricardo’s law of profits? 85. Explain the proposition that the rate of profits depends on the cost of labor, stating carefully what elements are included in cost of labor. 86. Explain what connection there may be between an increase of population and any of the elements entering into cost of labor. 87. What effect would an increase or diminution of population have upon cost of labor? 88. Explain Mill’s view as to the cost of labor being a function of three variables, considering the passages in which he says, 1. “If without labor becoming less efficient its remuneration fell, _no increase taking place in the cost of the articles composing that remuneration_;” 2. “If the laborer obtained a higher remuneration, _without any increased cheapness in the things composing it_; or if, without his obtaining more, _that which he did obtain would become more costly_”: profits in the last two cases would suffer a diminution; and discussing—Firstly, if the remuneration of labor falls, what can the cost of the articles composing that remuneration signify to the capitalist? Secondly, if the laborer gets a higher remuneration, what can the increased cheapness of the things composing it signify to the capitalist? 89. Is the contest between capital and labor permanent and fundamental? If not, give your reasons for your answer. 90. What is the effect on wages and profits of the introduction of machinery? RENT. 91. What connection exists between the law of Malthus and Ricardo’s doctrine of rent? 92. What is the reason why land-owners can demand rent?